The Greatest Game ever played seen for the first time on TV in 50 years.

Published



The Greatest Game Ever Played – 50 Years Later

By: Jim Williams

The Examiner

It has been 50 years since the Colts beat the New York Giants to win the 1958 NFL Championship Game. It was December 28th 1958 that the NFL broke through and became a TV sport

Saturday night at 9pm on ESPN for the first time since the game aired on NBC fans will see a reconstruction of the game. The original tape of the game was lost not long after it aired and so most visuals of that Colts-Giants game are black and white pictures.

It is hard for anyone under the age of 40 to believe that in 1958 the NFL did not have a game of the week. They were behind Major League Baseball, the Friday Night Fights, Bowling and college football when it came to TV.

It was 1962 before the NFL got a Game of the Week contract on CBS.

But if not for the Colts-Giants game it is hard to say when the NFL would have gotten a national game of the week contract.

I have seen parts of the ESPN Entertainment – NFL Films project and it is really a must see for any football fan. It took years for ESPN and NFL Films to get film from local TV stations in New York and Baltimore. They took some game films from both teams and picked up some home movies.

Once they got that film together each frame of the film was colorized and made digital so it is actually in HD. ESPN then brought together some of the players from both teams who actually played in the game. The network added to these vets some of the current day players and then they set these guys down and allowed them to watch the game in a living room set.

The interaction between guys like Art Donovan and Ex-New York Giant Michael Strahan is priceless.

For those who aren’t aware of how the game played out here are some of the highlights with the help of some research provided by the NFL.

When Colts fullback Alan Ameche burst through a hole for a one-yard touchdown with 6:45 left in overtime (left) – at 4:51 on a foggy, drizzly day – he took the National Football League with him into a new era.

The NFL would never be the same. America had discovered it.

It was the fourth time the teams had played each other that year – twice in preseason (with the Colts winning both) and once in the regular season, a Giants victory. New York tied with the Cleveland Browns in the Eastern Division with a 9-3 record, forcing a playoff. The Giants won, 10-0. Baltimore won the Western Division, also with a 9-3 record.

It was to be a classic confrontation of offense vs. defense. The Colts led the NFL in scoring with 381 points. They were led by 25-year-old quarterback Johnny Unitas signed two years before out of the Pittsburgh sandlots where he had been making $25 a game playing with the Bloomfield Rams. The Giants, glamorizing defense for the first time in NFL history, surrendered the league’s fewest points – 183.

The game featuring such dominant teams, things started slowly. The Giants were the first to score, on a 36-yard field goal by Pat Summerall with two minutes left in the first quarter. By halftime, the Colts had a 14-3 lead, and it looked like their high-powered offense would only add to that total in the second half.

It seemed that way as the half began. On their second series, the Colts drove from their 41-yard line to the Giants’ three. A score here would give them a daunting lead. It was time for New York’s vaunted defense to stiffen. They did exactly that. Three rushes gained the Colts two yards. It was now fourth and goal-to-go at the one. Time for a field goal.

“I decided that another touchdown would kill them right then and there,” said Baltimore head coach Weeb Ewbank. “I told Johnny to go for it.”

Unitas took the snap, pitched to Ameche, who faked a pass and then took off – only to be stopped cold by Jim Katcavage, Dick Modzelewski and Sam Huff. Four-yard loss. Giants ball. The momentum had swung. The Giants marched 95 yards on the next series, and 81 yards on the next, for touchdowns. Now they were ahead, 17-14, one minute into the fourth quarter. It was their turn to try to bury the opposition.

The Colts drove to the Giants’ 39. A Bert Rechichar 46-yard field-goal attempt was short. On the Colts’ next series, they were forced to punt. Time was winding down.

“At that point,” said Giants halfback Alex Webster, “we just had to keep the ball, run out the clock, and they’d never get another chance. We were so hot…everything was working well…it sure looked like our game.”

Then came the Gino Marchetti broken-leg controversy.

The Giants moved from the 19 to their 40, using up the clock on four running plays and a completed pass. On third and four, Frank Gifford took a handoff from quarterback Charrlie Conerly on a power sweep. He was met at the line by Marchetti and linebacker Don Shinnick, who were almost immediately, joined by 288-pound tackle Gene “Big Daddy” Lipscomb. The force and weight of Lipscomb’s arrival snapped Marchetti’s right leg above the ankle.

To this day, Gifford thinks he made the first down. “I made the first down,” he says. “But Marchetti broke his leg, and he was screaming like a wounded panther. There was a lot of confusion. A lot of time passed by while they carried Marchetti off the field. When they spotted the ball, it was placed short of the first-down marker.”

Go for it? Or punt? The Giants had the best punter in the business, Don Chandler. Giants head coach Jim Lee Howell waved him in. “Chandler could kick the ball all the way,” Howell said. “We thought we could stop them.”

Then came the final drive – Chandler punted 43 yards to the Colts’ 14, where Carl Taseff fair-caught it. There was 1:56 left, and the Colts had to go 86 yards for a touchdown.

“When we got in the huddle,” said wide receiver Raymond Berry, “I looked down the field and the goal posts looked like they were in Baltimore.”

“OK, guys, here we go,” said Unitas simply. His first two passes were incomplete. On third down, he connected with Lenny Moore for 11 yards. On first, he missed L.G. DUPRE on a long route. Then Johnny U turned to Berry. Unitas to Berry for 25. Unitas to Berry for 15. Unitas to Berry for 22.

The Colts were now at the New York 13 with 19 seconds left, but no time outs left. Kicker Steve Myhra raced onto the field. “I told myself I better not miss it,” he says, “or it would be a long, cold winter back on the farm in North Dakota.”

Myhra’s 20-yard field goal with seven seconds left created the first sudden-death overtime in NFL championship game history.

The winning drive that made NFL history – Unitas called tails on the coin toss. It came up heads. The Giants elected to receive, but gained only four yards before Chandler punted to Taseff again. The next 13 plays confirmed the “ice-in-his-veins” legend of Johnny Unitas.

“Johnny told us in the huddle before we began that drive that we were going to take the ball right down and score,” said Ameche. “And we all believed him.”

Unitas moved the Colts 80 yards in those 13 plays. He put Baltimore into position after completing a 12-yarder to Berry. First-and-goal at the Giants’ eight-yard line. A fan raced onto the field. The officials called time out. Unitas went over to talk to Ewbank.

“Keep it on the ground,” Ewbank said. “We don’t want an interception here. We can hit the field goal if running plays don’t work.”

Unitas followed instructions – initially. He handed off to Ameche for a one-yard gain off right tackle. Then he stunned everybody – especially Ewbank – by fading back and floating a six-yard pass along the right sideline to wide receiver Jim Mutscheller.

Third-and-goal at the Giants’ one. Unitas called “16 power,” a play designed to send Ameche through the right side of the line. Mutscheller and Moore leveled Giants linebacker Cliff Livingston and safety Emlen Tunnell. Colts tackle George Preas and guard Alex Sandusky cleared out a mammoth hole that the 220-pound Ameche roared through, literally falling from his momentum after crossing the goal line.

It was 4:51 in the afternoon. The NFL had arrived.

See the game again 9pm on Saturday night on ESPN.

Once again thanks to the NFL for some of the quotes used in this story.