Cheers & Jeers » Overrated alert: DE Aaron Maybin

Published



The evaluator, based on talking to scouts and his own knowledge, panned the notion of Vernon Gholston as a top-10 pick in 2008. Or even a first-round pick. Some teams had him no better than a second-round pick.

Now the evaluator has a new target: Penn State defensive end Aaron Maybin.

He’s unanimously projected as a high first-round pick, possibly going around the top 10. However, he only had one really good season, posting 12 sacks for the Nittany Lions this past fall after being a backup in his only other season (he redshirted in 2006).

He put on 20 pounds after the season to prepare for  life as an NFL end. He’s a major risk, according to some.

“That’s a slam dunk,’’ the evaluator said. I’d like to see him make a play here and there. He’s not as unproductive as Gholston was, but he did not make nearly the amount of plays for a guy who is a top 10 or 15 pick. He doesn’t jump out at you and say, ‘I’m the one making all the plays.’”