NFL too eager to hand out individual awards

Published



Matt Ryan had a great rookie season, and the Colts certainly wouldn’t have made the playoffs without quarterback Peyton Manning. Coach Mike Smith worked wonders guiding Atlanta from the bottom to the top of the NFC South Division in his first season.

But is Ryan the league’s Offensive Rookie of the Year? Is Manning really the Most Valuable Player and Smith the Coach of the Year?

The NFL says “yes.”

I say “no.”

Sports –be it high school, college or professional — aren’t about the regular season. They’re about the playoffs. The regular season is the opening act to the main event.

Just look at the 2006 Ravens, the 2006 Chargers and the 2007 Patriots — all had great regular seasons and all underachieved when the games mattered most, in the postseason. The Ravens’ collapse to the Colts in the playoffs overshadowed their 13-3 regular season, just as the Chargers’ loss in their first playoff game got their coach fired. New England? The team that went undefeated until losing to the Giants in Super Bowl XLII can’t be cast in the same light as any of the three Patriots’ teams that won the Super Bowl.

If greatness is determined after all games have been played, then why can’t the NFL wait until all the games have been played to award accolades?

If the NFL named the Offensive Rookie of the Year right now, who is more deserving: Ryan, whose team flamed out in the first round, or Joe Flacco, who is the first rookie quarterback in league history to win two playoff games? I’ll take the guy who accomplished what no quarterback –not Joe Montana, Roger Staubach or Johnny Unitas — accomplished over a guy with a better stats. After all, winning trumps everything.

Altering the time frame wouldn’t change the outcome of every award. New England linebacker Jerod Mayo still would be the Defensive Rookie of the Year, and Pennington still would be the Comeback Player of the Year.

But the NFL doesn’t see it this way.

You don’t judge a book without reading the final chapter, just as you don’t give Academy Awards to actors based on their performances during the first three-quarters of a movie.

And the last time I checked, teachers don’t determine students’ grades until after final exams.

Manning didn’t pass his final exam. He was fantastic in leading the Colts to the playoffs, but is it too much to ask that the player deemed “most valuable” convert a third-and-two to win a playoff game?

Now, let’s look at Kurt Warner and Donovan McNabb. Sure, both were good –not great — during the regular season. But Warner has the Cardinals –repeat, Cardinals! — on the cusp of the Super Bowl. And all McNabb has done is lead the Eagles to road wins over the NFC North champion Vikings and defending Super Bowl champion Giants. A few weeks ago, he was such a pariah in the City of Brotherly Love he might as well have been forced to wear a scarlet letter like Hester Prynne.

Their greatness the past two weeks made everyone forget what happened in October and November. That’s something only players who are “truly valuable” can do.

Too bad the NFL doesn’t see it the same way.

jgallo@baltimoreexaminer.com