Football purists were aghast last month when Eagles quarterback Donovan McNabb admitted he didn’t know NFL games could end in a tie.
But McNabb’s ignorance pales in comparison with the uncertainty at the end of the 1958 NFL Championship Game, when players were unaware that a tie could be broken.
Recommended Stories
That is one of the intriguing footnotes explored Saturday when ESPN shows the Baltimore Colts’ historic 23-17 victory over the New York Giants. “The Greatest Game Ever Played” will air at 9 p.m., after the Heisman Trophy Show.
Viewers will see players mystified after Baltimore’s Steve Myhra kicks a 20-yard field goal to make it 17-17.
“Nobody knew what was going on,” said Colts flanker Lenny Moore by teleconference last week. “We thought the game was over and it was going to end in a tie.”
On the sideline, from his knees, Giants’ kicker Pat Summerall watched Myhra’s kick sail just inside the left upright. He turned to captain Kyle Rote, for clarity.
“I said, ‘What do we do now?’” said Summerall. “He said, ‘I think we’ve got play some more, but I’m not sure. Let me go find out.’”
Players describe that Dec. 28 game, 50 years ago, as a perfect storm of timing, characters, and circumstances. It was the start of the TV age. The game was set in media-centric New York City. And the matchup was intriguing as the Colts, full of castoffs and in their sixth year of existence, were cast as lovable underdogs against the powerful, glamorous, media-savvy Giants.
Most of all, the game was riveting as Colts quarterback Johnny Unitas directed two brilliant drives — one in the final two minutes to tie the game and the other to win it.
To Giants running back Frank Gifford (above), the most compelling aspect was overtime.
“Television sets were just coming into vogue,” said Gifford. “People turned on their TVs and there was a football game being played in the fifth quarter. It was something you would recognize and remember.”