Every election cycle, we’re treated to a spate of articles about the need for a third party, like this one from Matt Miller, which typically trigger responses like this one from Chris Cillizza about why a third-party candidacy isn’t politically feasible. But few articles recognize a more basic problem with such a proposition: even if a third-party candidate could get elected, it would be nearly impossible for that person to get anything accomplished as president.
The reason why is that the most effective tool that a president has to get his agenda through Congress is to appeal to the loyalty of members of his own party, in part because their political fortunes are tied together. Maybe, in cases where an independent president is immensely popular, or the legislation he’s pushing has overwhelming public support, he’d be able to get some minor things passed. But on the biggest and most controversial issues of the day, such as reforming entitlements, reining in spending, reforming the tax code, and addressing health care inflation, it’s hard to see many lawmakers taking tough votes for a third-party president.