The public hates inflation. Ever-rising prices reduce prosperity for households and businesses. There are daily articles about high prices for gasoline, electricity, and beef. But rarely does the media spotlight inflation caused by greedy public sector unions that use their monopoly bargaining power to extract absurd wages and benefits.
For the first time since 1994, five unions representing more than 3,500 workers on the Long Island Rail Road, the country’s busiest passenger rail network, are on strike. The workers walked off the job on Saturday after negotiations that had gone on for more than a year fell apart.
Recommended Stories
On the surface, the sticking points between the unions and the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, the New York state agency that manages the railroad, seem trivial. The unions want a salary increase of 5% for the next year of their contract, which begins in June. The workers say they need 5% to keep up with inflation. The MTA is offering 3%.
What the MTA should be offering the unions is a wage increase of zero. Compensation for workers on the LIRR is the highest in the United States transit system, driven by the monopoly power of a strong union in a state controlled by far-left Democrats who kowtow to unions to win votes in elections. The average base salary for an LIRR employee is roughly $120,000 to $130,000, but total take-home pay is frequently much higher due to work rule structures and overtime requirements. Overtime is a major component of compensation for these workers. It is common for employees to earn an additional $60,000 to $100,000 or more in overtime pay. Top earners on the LIRR make up to $300,000 annually.
If wages more than four times higher than the average salary of an American worker are not egregious enough, union workers also enjoy “Cadillac” health insurance. Out-of-pocket healthcare costs are about $25 for a doctor’s visit. Workers also receive expansive prescription benefits and comprehensive dental coverage. The economic value of health insurance for a worker with a spouse and children approaches $40,000 a year. Importantly, that is a tax-free benefit.
The compensation and benefits packages for employees of the Long Island Rail Road are difficult to justify to taxpayers and commuters who already face some of the highest transportation costs in the country. The scale of compensation at the LIRR now reflects a public sector system distorted by political favoritism, excessive overtime practices, and weak accountability.
The MTA, which manages the LIRR, struggles with chronic financial deficits, aging infrastructure, and repeated fare hikes. Yet despite these financial pressures, labor costs continue to consume a massive share of the agency’s budget.
Productivity on the LIRR is also a significant problem. The railroad has frequently been criticized for outdated work rules that make modernization difficult and increase labor requirements beyond what technology would otherwise necessitate. In many industries, automation and operational reform have improved efficiency and reduced costs. But powerful public sector unions resist reforms that could reduce overtime opportunities or alter staffing practices.
This matters because affordable transportation into New York City is essential to the state’s economy. Excessive labor costs divert resources away from system modernization, station improvements, and service reliability. Riders pay more while often receiving mediocre service, delays, and overcrowding. Taxpayers are repeatedly asked to fund bailouts while structural inefficiencies remain untouched.
RESISTANCE TO DATA CENTERS GROWS NATIONWIDE
The LIRR compensation packages are a symbol of the abusive power of public sector unions.
Wages and benefits are shaped more by political power and entrenched union influence than by market discipline or operational efficiency. Without reform, taxpayers and commuters will continue paying the price through higher fares, higher taxes, and declining confidence in public institutions.
James Rogan is a former U.S. foreign service officer who later worked in law and finance for over 30 years. Now he writes a daily note on markets, economics, politics, and social issues.
