Restoring America

Conservative values, National renewal

Who speaks for the state in the courtroom?

Published



Across the country, a quiet but consequential shift is underway in public litigation. Increasingly, cities and counties are outsourcing major lawsuits to private law firms operating on contingency-fee arrangements. While often presented as a cost-saving measure, this trend raises broader questions about accountability, federalism, and who ultimately speaks for the public interest when legal actions carry statewide economic and policy consequences. Left unchecked, the growing reliance on privately driven public litigation risks blurring the line between public authority and private financial incentive.

These arrangements have become increasingly common in recent years as local officials find them attractive because they avoid upfront legal costs and promise significant payouts. However, they give outside counsel a powerful role in shaping litigation normally handled by state attorneys general, who have traditionally been empowered to speak for the state and its people in such matters of broad public importance. The result has been a complex and often fragmented environment in which the constitutional role of the attorney general is weakened, leaving states and their political subdivisions to pursue overlapping and disunified claims against the same defendants which ultimately weakens bargaining power and prolongs litigation.

Trusted reporting.Unlimited access.

Subscribe for full access to Washington Examiner coverage, expert political analysis, and subscriber-only journalism.

Get Unlimited Access

Already a member? Log in

Cancel anytime.